[SOLVED]PGC6044 wrong result

[pi-news]

Accused User Accounts: cpl.1337, lucker, feid, giokas, shaoran_san

Game name: PGC6044

Offence of user: drawed the game, after loosing

Hostbot : DA-VIP-01


replay: http://www.mediafire.com/file/23wncedkezf/laplay.w3g


took place in 26:40 when sentinel players started leaving...


end it scourge ty

[D3athKnight]

Man understand plz u must use the correct Form.READ THIS http://www.dota-alliance.com/board/showthread.php?t=4703 anD EDIT ur POst stop posts when u dont know..I dont see now.If u edit i will see. Learn How to post reports etc.

FOR EXAMPLE'
* Accused User Account : D3ATHKNIGHT,

* Game Name :PGC000

* Offence of User :Leaver

* Hostbot : DA-VIP-01

And after of this write ur opinion and the replay

[KicA]

I'll watch the replay but i won't change the score or warn the following users until you've edited your post.

[KicA]

A weird game. Sentinel had the upper hand in that game and then suddenly cpl.1337 (Priestess of the Moon) left the game. I think he got disconnect as for Lucker (Enigma) he left a few seconds later could be a plug realizing that they couldn't win without their carry in that game. Since it was 3v5 Rooftrellen (Giokas) then left without any reason whatsoever. When someone leaves he is treated like he forfeited and since 2 already left/disconnected it was 2/3 team members that "forfeited". When Giokas left it was decided. 3/3 "forfeits" are enough for scourge to win the game even though sentinel would win. That is the way i see it. Need other staff members opinions. Edit your post aswell, you were given the correct format.

[JuVe913]

I will do a deep analysis on this game:

Sentinel Chat:

About shaoran-san (Lion)

30:08 [All] shaoran-san (Lion): shut up noob
30:26 [All] shaoran-san (Lion): you just noob so shut up


About Weezy_Baby (Balanar)

12:50 [Allies] Weezy_Baby (Balanar): i told ya potm will fuck us all
12:56 [Allies] Weezy_Baby (Balanar): deep throat

About ABC_Schuetze (Slardar)

16:50 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): sure he own u
17:01 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): u failed hard

26:01 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): omg man
26:15 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): fucking bad picks and lowskilled <.<


26:53 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): sure i did
27:02 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): wtf we need medusa for?
27:18 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): and leshrac
27:24 [Allies] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): both heros suck in this combo


About pi-news (Axe)

25:56 [Allies] pi-news (Axe): u suck


All the other members of Sentinel and Scourge stayed clean and out of flames or disrespect of their own team mates

30:27 cpl.1337 has lost the connection (timed out).
31:10 Lucker has lost the connection (timed out).
31:16 Giokas has left the game voluntarily.

These leavers were From Sentinel Side all

Suggestions:

As it seems its still a hard game but,

Giokas 40% For Leaving(Even though he was winning,based on stats and on how his opponents were behaving)

ABC_Schuetze 30% For Bad Manners

Weezy_Baby 15% For Some Not nice Words like "Fuck us"

Result Suggestion:

The game should end Sentinel/Draw , because none accepted the end 2 that was suggested at the end and they just left

And the proof is:

31:21 [All] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): end 2
31:21 [All] pi-news (Axe): go end 2
31:21 [All] Weezy_Baby (Balanar): muahaha
31:22 [Allies] pi-news (Axe): fast
31:23 [All] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): ...
31:24 [All] prime_number (Leshrac): ABC_Schuetze has left the game voluntarily.
31:24 ABC_Schuetze (Slardar) (1-4) has left the game.
31:27 shaoran-san (Lion) (9-2) has left the game.
31:27 prime_number (Leshrac) (5-6) has left the game.
31:27 Feid (Spectre) (1-2) has left the game.
31:27 ddubb (Gorgon) (2-5) has left the game.
31:27 Weezy_Baby (Balanar) (2-5) has left the game.

Abc_Schuetze , pi-news 20% For Wrong Result (The game didnt end and they wanted to win because some people left without breaking the TREE)

[KicA]

31:21 [All] ABC_Schuetze (Slardar): end 2
31:21 [All] pi-news (Axe): go end 2
31:21 [All] Weezy_Baby (Balanar): muahaha

The first 2 guys said "end 2" and "go end 2"=2/3 and Weezy_Baby clearly laughed sarcasticly and with joy(he clearly wanted to score it to scourge as you can see so its 3/3). But since sentinel left without saying a thing its as if they forfeited but i need someone else's opinion on this aswell. Thats how i see it.

[JuVe913]

they didnt forfeit anyway so the game was still going.So i support to end draw the game because no ff's applies,just many leavers.

[D3athKnight]

This is clearly .end draw ,There were some leavers and i vote to draw.For abuses now,The disconnects i dont give warn,But i will give warn to giokas 40% cause the bot said Giokas has left the game voluntarily. it means he left free. I agree Juve for ur warns,But ABC_Schuetze must get warn 20%,40% it is unfair,,Weezy_Baby 15% warn i dont agree because used the word fuck us? he didhnt flam .And me sometimes i use the fuck but in allies not in all .Also, Abc_Schuetze , pi-news get warns 20% for wrong result

And i will say again the game is Draw.Thx for posting

!ACCEPTED